How was it constructive? Constructive criticism includes some sort of advice on how to improve technique. I saw none of that. Only a 'you should've done this differently' sort of response - which is totally useless. =P
As for anyone looking to continue this line of conversation, I'd really rather not get drawn into a debate with anyone about what constitutes constructive criticism, so let's just let this discussion die here, shall we?
It's called criticism you hypocritic noob. WE all judge people and first sight as we do things like you, I, and many others, makign you even more hypocritic thus turning this trade of comments into an ironic and pointless debate, since you love fourm bashing so much. I had no intention whatsoever to put the OP down, it was just criticism to make it better, I admit I'm not an artist myself, but you can't expect people to like what they s ee first hand.
Summary: You are a hypocritic forum-bashing retarded noob
Lol. What is it with people these days? Good lord. I really don't want every single thread I make turn into a debate.
I'd really like to understand what you mean by 'forum bashing' because I see none of it in my post. Really, I just can't see how you could even begin to believe that what I said was derogatory in any way.
And yes, what you said was criticism, but that doesn't mean I have to like it. I've always been an advocate of constructive criticism that promotes the flow of ideas, improvement of technique, etc. I'm allowed to respond to criticism in whatever fashion I want - assuming I'm not offensive (which I wasn't). What I say still stands. I still think it's silly to say that someone else's art should be one way or another - in this case the roman numeral I (in the center of the III). Who says it has to be flat? Art is about freedom of expression - in this case I can make the I look however I want.
As for calling me a hypocrite - again, I fail to see where I have acted hypocritical or said anything hypocritical at all. You told me how my art should be, I responded saying that you can't tell me how to make my art better. That goes for all art. You can't improve art - only an artist's technique - and whether or not an I is curved or flat on the bottom has nothing to do with technique.
As far as being a 'retard' or a 'noob' goes, I'm not even going to bother trying to explain why you are wrong on both counts. Suffice it to say that my intelligence and longevity on these boards is sufficient enough to warrant neither of these insults.
But, I'm fairly open-minded most of the time, so if you can present me with some evidence proving that I'm a 'hypocritic forum-bashing retarded noob', I may reconsider my stance here.
If you plan on doing so, send it to me via PM as debates like this are better kept private.
PS: Flaming is a bannable offense on these boards btw, so I'd recommend not doing so ever again - to anyone. For now, I have merely added an infaction point to your account.
no offense u guys, i think it looks welldone and cool but there is little to no chance that Tyrael is evil, it's just a theory that has been repeated and has been rejected many times, maybe make a righteous version out of Tyrael? just an idea
It's true. I myself have dismissed the concept. I did this as a sort of indulgence for those fans out there who are embracing the idea though.
As for anyone looking to continue this line of conversation, I'd really rather not get drawn into a debate with anyone about what constitutes constructive criticism, so let's just let this discussion die here, shall we?
Lol. What is it with people these days? Good lord. I really don't want every single thread I make turn into a debate.
I'd really like to understand what you mean by 'forum bashing' because I see none of it in my post. Really, I just can't see how you could even begin to believe that what I said was derogatory in any way.
And yes, what you said was criticism, but that doesn't mean I have to like it. I've always been an advocate of constructive criticism that promotes the flow of ideas, improvement of technique, etc. I'm allowed to respond to criticism in whatever fashion I want - assuming I'm not offensive (which I wasn't). What I say still stands. I still think it's silly to say that someone else's art should be one way or another - in this case the roman numeral I (in the center of the III). Who says it has to be flat? Art is about freedom of expression - in this case I can make the I look however I want.
As for calling me a hypocrite - again, I fail to see where I have acted hypocritical or said anything hypocritical at all. You told me how my art should be, I responded saying that you can't tell me how to make my art better. That goes for all art. You can't improve art - only an artist's technique - and whether or not an I is curved or flat on the bottom has nothing to do with technique.
As far as being a 'retard' or a 'noob' goes, I'm not even going to bother trying to explain why you are wrong on both counts. Suffice it to say that my intelligence and longevity on these boards is sufficient enough to warrant neither of these insults.
But, I'm fairly open-minded most of the time, so if you can present me with some evidence proving that I'm a 'hypocritic forum-bashing retarded noob', I may reconsider my stance here.
If you plan on doing so, send it to me via PM as debates like this are better kept private.
PS: Flaming is a bannable offense on these boards btw, so I'd recommend not doing so ever again - to anyone. For now, I have merely added an infaction point to your account.
http://www.diablofans.com/forums/showthread.php?t=7869
It's true. I myself have dismissed the concept. I did this as a sort of indulgence for those fans out there who are embracing the idea though.
Lol just an idea. Anyways, thanks for the comment.