I don't really see how one could consider taking enchantress.
Except for the armor aura if you play with a lot of hp.
The scoundrel gives you far more damage boost (10% half the time) and the templar can block or distract enemies.
i found the scoundrel to do some pretty depressing dmg too even when geared also. I geared my enchantress decently (and inexpensively) using a pretty decent 1000ish DPS Rare 2h weapon that I found and bought some cheap mass int+vit rings neck and follower special and her damage is actually pretty damn decent. Her force push (which I find to be quite helpful when kiting) hits for over 20k in inferno and her auto attacks hit 5k. She can also amp monsters for 10% dmg but it can be hard to tell if its active.
My scoundrel on the other hand lists about 1.5k more damage on the follower screen and yet hits much weaker with no "nuke" ability. The only thing moderately useful about him is his last 2 abilities (the on crit -> 10% dmg or 3% passive crit) or if you were to equip him with a frost dmg weapon + multishot to slow down enemies. Though that would require him to be alive for a chance of some additional utility.
The only time I ever use the templar is for his magic find. Past act 1 he wasn't surviving any more hits than the other 2 while providing "less utility." A heal? Please, I was going to get 1 shot regardless
0
i found the scoundrel to do some pretty depressing dmg too even when geared also. I geared my enchantress decently (and inexpensively) using a pretty decent 1000ish DPS Rare 2h weapon that I found and bought some cheap mass int+vit rings neck and follower special and her damage is actually pretty damn decent. Her force push (which I find to be quite helpful when kiting) hits for over 20k in inferno and her auto attacks hit 5k. She can also amp monsters for 10% dmg but it can be hard to tell if its active.
My scoundrel on the other hand lists about 1.5k more damage on the follower screen and yet hits much weaker with no "nuke" ability. The only thing moderately useful about him is his last 2 abilities (the on crit -> 10% dmg or 3% passive crit) or if you were to equip him with a frost dmg weapon + multishot to slow down enemies. Though that would require him to be alive for a chance of some additional utility.
The only time I ever use the templar is for his magic find. Past act 1 he wasn't surviving any more hits than the other 2 while providing "less utility." A heal? Please, I was going to get 1 shot regardless