the Schaefer is better. If you had a perfect non ancient furnace then it would change. back to the furnace. Ultimately it comes down to RNG with Grifts.
Tough choice i would try and find out if the 20% elite dmg is worth more than the weapon dmg. My estimated guess is Schaefer but i would ask a math guy.
Hey Guys
I have just gotten my first gift of the season. Should I gift either of these weapons?
My Profile: http://us.battle.net/d3/en/profile/thakandar-1188/hero/57624797
The weapons: http://imgur.com/lBOAC1L (included the swk ammy in the pic as it has +lightning)
Thank you!
the Schaefer is better. If you had a perfect non ancient furnace then it would change. back to the furnace. Ultimately it comes down to RNG with Grifts.
THEY HATE US, CUZ THEY AIN'T US
Tough choice i would try and find out if the 20% elite dmg is worth more than the weapon dmg. My estimated guess is Schaefer but i would ask a math guy.
Hammer will kill trash faster. Furnace will kill elites faster. If you have 20% lightning on neck, then here is what the hammer does...
100 x 20% = 120
100 x 43% = 143
143/120 = 1.19. That 23% is actually only increasing your dps by 19% because it is additive with the 20% on neck.
19% + the 17% from the tooltip is 36%.
VS 43% against elites with furnace.