Achievement Bug Thread 2

  • This is thread number two! The other thread reached its maximum post limit. You can find a link to that thread at the bottom of the post.

    This thread is being made in continuation of the old thread in hopes that a resolution can be brought to the bug that is not giving credit to users for their achievements.

    Everyone posting their bugged achievements please use the format below. This shows that you reported it on the forum like they keep telling everyone to do, but also you provided picture evidence of it being bugged.

    Please post your bugged achievements in this format:
    <code>Battletag: name#1234 (or the link to your diablo 3 profile)
    Achievement: (put the specific achievement(s) here. english only please!)
    Picture: (post a picture of the achievement here showing all the boxes checked but no reward)</code>

    <code>Archival Studies
      BloodyJester#1317
      Grantig#2809
      Xaios#1745

    Beastmaster of Caldeum
      Hyrma#2441
      Gamagori#2431
      Shadeslayer#2530
      Vinbard#1592

    Beastmaster of the High Heavens
      Angron#2958
      C53#2639
      Heix #2826
      MrCrapouli#2794
      Peacemaker#2609
      SaltyDaveIV#1453
      Sidis#1419
      Tandre#1679
      TRUCK#1238
      Tyrion#1654

    Beastmaster of Tristram
      Anroel#2430
      Aremi#2265
      Bloedstorm#2390
      Bombs#2664
      CH1LL1E#2611
      ChanceCZ#1159
      Dakafire#1510
      Doomsongson#1887
      Draylock#1728
      Faith#2661
      Grunaldi #2348
      Herumor#2189
      Isao#2516
      Kamaz#2719
      Kazaam#1895
      kts#2518
      lolicow#1545
      Luurtz#2550
      Mekamoari#2861
      Mietzi#2490
      mrtrob#2808
      Pih4ir#2885
      proXimo#1152
      Rhadric#2554
      sandwraith#2962
      Sogron#2666
      Spawacz#2232
      TheRedeemer#2323
      Tosai#2351
      Xiet#1734
      Xsn#2361
      Zaser77#1797
      ZeN#2621

    Best Dressed
      EhnnZhed#2506

    Bewitched
      Agravain316#1857
      Bear44#1475
      Odysseus#2130

    Black Soulstone
      Champloncar#2339
      Genez#2639
      Genuine#2503
      Hyrma#2441
      InityRV#2898
      Rhuiax#2984
      Ryuk#1847
      Sephiroth#2674
      Shadeslayer#2530
      TODD #2211
      Varyah#2968

    Bless You
      Clear#1821
      Debigbos#2614
      downsideup16#1506
      Grezen1o#2762
      Minko#1655
      slug#1648
      Solerik#1394
      Thelmas#1424
      VyRianS#1747

    Bone Collector
      keepeR#2363

    Champions of Ivgorod
      AmakusaShino#6595

    Comfort of Strangers
      Klarado#2932
      Nakor#2612
      Sharyel#2739
      Tosai#2351

    Cut Above
      crouch#3892

    Death Metalworking
      Genthor#2282

    Elitist Bubble
      Juanzu#2777

    Elitist Few
      Genthor#2282

    Eternal War
      Necksnapper#1372

    Exalted Few
      baker#2492

    Field Work
      Angel#2869
      BarBass#1482
      Cogite#2904
      Guran#1517
      Ickyz#2687
      JokeR2in1#2403
      Kousin#2652
      Krystalus #2121
      Kurgan#2633
      MNeMoNiCuz#1333
      Nahimana#1413
      Ordkomber#1333
      Rizlake2#2239
      Tandre#1679
      Tawyn#2868
      TheRedeemer#2323
      VampieL#2456
      Vinbard#1592
      Vlade#2872

    Fistful of Gems
      Angron#2958
      mrdiablo#2937

    For the Order
      Blacksarevok#1762
      Champloncar#2339
      proto84#1888

    Fresh Meat
      randmtsk#1287
      SevenBullets#1230

    From Arreat to Xiansai
      Grimbeorn#2657
      LOKKAIN#2233
      Nightowl#2378
      zhira#1325

    Garbage Disposal
      Seraph#1583

    Garden of Heavenly Delights
      Angron#2958
      Champloncar#2339
      SaltyDaveIV#1453
      Sidis#1419
      Thallex#1978
      Zae#1259

    Grand Beastmaster of Sanctuary
      Enmity#1535
      Patrizzle#2351

    Great Revival
      Alexey7045#2724
      xZoeNeoZx#6350

    Heralds of the New Dawn
      AmakusaShino#6595
      Moriarty#2248
      Nightowl#2378

    Hassling Haedrig
      StellarWing#1246

    Heroes of the North
      Nightowl#2378

    Historian of Arreat
      teiler#2748
      W33ch#2177

    Historian of Caldeum
      Alphahelm#2513
      ePat#1403
      Omoikane#1825

    Historian of the High Heavens
      Lore#2827
      Qsram#1305
      Raki#2199
      Terence#3286

    Historian of Tristram
      Bondo#1349

    I Got What You Need
      Demonik#2964
      killerek#2951
      PiercingEyes#1243
      Xyfir#2360

    Iced Out
      TheCrusader#2947

    In a Hurry
      Malocor#1248

    In The Mountains
      Alphahelm#2513
      Anroel#2430
      Bromigo#2148
      Cazjr#2879
      Dakafire#1510
      Demonik#2964
      DenMCX#1666
      Dirty#1137
      Drugrim#2511
      Echard#1748
      Kamaz#2719
      Killmaster#2893
      Kurgan#2633
      Kristopher#2136
      LiquidGuy#1538
      Luurtz#2550
      Mietzi#2490
      Nakor#2612
      Neikei#2201
      Nightowl#2378
      Remorix#1324
      Sylmarr#2212
      Tosai#2351
      Vossekop#2840

    It's Just Us
      Vortex#2132

    Jewel of the East
      Arbee#2495
      DoomMaster#2151
      Generaljab#2721
      Hennett#2234
      Kroman#2339
      liandroa#1280
      Natux#2784
      Yasinx#2250
      Zarfot#1208
      Zwetser#2470

    Judge of Character
      ari4n#1856
      BKGeno#1425
      BlueSoul#1584
      Bohun#2483
      Chronicle#1766
      Clabuc#1719
      DalDaddy#1964
      EizN#2523
      FuDaVan#2993
      GeneralWaste#2954
      Herugurth#2790
      Hibike#2292
      JPNORONHA#1533
      Korlian#2486
      LiNGoTaZoS#2346
      Meaduuk#2206
      MutantGnome#6483
      Poulpos#2822
      QuasiByte#2575
      Requiemourn#2279
      SatNavMan#2450
      SilverD#2963
      Takava#1508
      Truder#2441
      Underko#2505
      Warggs#2121
      Wargoat#1358

    Just Deserts
      Bunnysmasher#1971
      Dragonsoul#2848
      Ickyz#2687
      JMK#2192
      LarelAnorien#2989
      Longshot#2335
      Macabra#2713
      Mrkvus#2443
      piecat #1216
      SuperLamo#2647
      svardie#2643
      Yamantaka#2666
      Yasinx#2250

    Know It All
      TRUCK#1238

    Last of the Horadrim
      Aremi#2265
      Bloedstorm#2390
      Bombs#2664
      Bromigo#2148
      Bunnysmasher#1971
      Dakafire#1510
      Densome#2798
      Dirty#1137
      Ehatre#2898
      Elshinow#2949
      Farax#2987
      Isao#2516
      JackoV#2144
      Kalenas#2536
      Kazaam#1895
      Lai#2669
      latschen6#2272
      lolicow#1545
      Luurtz#2550
      Mekamoari#2861
      Mietzi#2490
      MNeMoNiCuz#1333
      Nakor#2612
      Nashan#2538
      Nealliam#1455
      Nightowl#2378
      Pih4ir#2885
      proXimo#1152
      Rhadric#2554
      sandwraith#2962
      Seliah#2787
      Sogron#2666
      Spawacz#2232
      SteelHammer#2661
      TheRedeemer#2323
      Tosai#2351
      VampieL#2456
      Xalazar#2900
      Xsn#2361
      Yossarion#2850
      Yumeka#2411
      ZeN#2621

    Market Research
      Smithey77#2936

    More Than Stories
      Sephiroth#2674
      sickness#1671

    Mouth of Hell
      Elit#2835
      Enmity#1535
      Hazardous#1401
      Highbrid#2589
      Pulp#1156
      Serendipity#1183
      Tyrion#1654

    Navigating The Labyrinth
      Genuine#2503
      Mauldo#1621
      TODD #2211
      YaTne#2684

    Nice Place to Visit
      bg2026#2698
      Binks#2142
      Guilmar#2483
      MrT#1308
      VampieL#2456

    O’er the Ramparts We Watched
      Bear44#1475
      jackel668#2234
      st0ne#2356

    Oh the Places Youll Go
      Berdugo#1778

    One Percent
      Aiyi #1725
      Genthor#2282
      ZeD#2436

    Out of the Shadows
      Aiyi #1725
      Akira#2876
      Andrewt#1561
      Brad#1628
      cobra#2629
      Genthor#2282
      George#1748
      Ghostmu#2179
      Helias#2349
      Henador#2947
      Homizuko#2376
      Kamuel#2346
      Kapim#1688
      Kiril#2480
      Klarado#2932
      Kousin#2652
      LastSigh#2936
      Phlox#2672
      pixel#1478
      Poinard#6169
      shadowarg#1490
      Silence#2978
      Silverfox#1996
      Sirdante#2663
      Strathi3#2919
      svardie#2643
      Syntaxx#1859
      Tornado#2254
      tritium#1691
      wfx#2339
      yukj#2591
      Zodcra#1105
      Zwetser#2470

    Pink'd
      Seraph#1583

    Quick Study
      Jimmy2Shoes#1271
      morgwynn#1286

    Return Business
      bg2026#2698
      Debigbos#2614
      keraoc#2126
      khuba#2111
      Luurtz#2550
      Ordkomber#1333
      Rizlake2#2239
      Wraithverge#1409

    Sales and Tales
      Xyfir#2360

    Sanctum Savants
      Grimbeorn#2657

    Secrets of the Ages
      Champloncar#2339
      Sidis#1419

    Slaughter Field Five
      frostnacht#2413

    Stay Awhile and Listen
      Andariel#1904
      Anghild#2379
      Ehatre#2898
      kasimmorathi#1387
      Pyro#2456
      Ragnar#2404
      Shadowraziel#2696

    Staying Gold
      Ymlaen#2298

    Such Great Heights
      Xaios#1745

    Taking Notes
      Benitune#1344
      Cyndre#1901
      Flok#1591

    There Will Definitely Be Blood
      Asbel#2890
      Bloedstorm#2390
      Bombs#2664
      Ehatre#2898
      Farax#2987
      粉紅切開總是黑#3792
      Lai#2669
      Nickk40#2824
      Pih4ir#2885
      Rhadric#2554
      sandwraith#2962
      Sogron#2666
      Soto#2187
      Vinbard#1592

    Thorough Investigation
      ace700#1585
      Debigbos#2614
      Howler#1244
      keraoc#2126
      Neikei#2201
      NoctvrnaL#2863
      Nonick#2634
      Photato#2295
      Reelix#2213
      Ripper182#1645
      Torque#1908
      VampieL#2456
      Xsn#2361

    To Catch a Thief
      Champloncar#2339
      proto84#1888

    To The Smithy
      tdang#1799

    Unparalleled Splendor
      EhnnZhed#2506
      Este#2663
      Genuine#2503
      Gymnasty#1374
      Hyrma#2441
      pl4c3b0#2569
      sajinist#1771
      Valdor#2796
      YaTne#2684

    Unique Collection
      Davidcore#2718

    Victory and Sacrifice
      Angron#2958
      Champloncar#2339
      Heix #2826
      SaltyDaveIV#1453
      TRUCK#1238
      Zae#1259

    Wages of Sin
      DrPewPew#2312
      ekze#1992
      Elit#2835
      Enmity#1535
      Hasinbinseen#1960
      Onigreed#2417
      Serendipity#1183
      Sinner#6950
      Xyfir#2360

    Wanderer of Caldeum
      Hyrma#2441
      Zarfot#1208

    Wanderer of the High Heavens
      Xaios#1745

    Wanderer of Tristram
      Bloedstorm#2390
      Dakafire#1510
      Farax#2987
      MNeMoNiCuz#1333
      Nightowl#2378
      Sogron#2666

    Warriors of a Broken World
      Grimbeorn#2657
      zhira#1325

    Warriors of the North
      Craon#2739

    Wheel of Misfortune
      Darkblue006#1531
    </code>

    https://us.battle.net/d3/en/forum/topic/11161436067?page=1#1
    https://us.battle.net/d3/en/forum/topic/10014141548?page=1
    http://us.battle.net/d3/en/forum/topic/11042104921#1
    http://us.battle.net/d3/en/forum/topic/11040344635#1
    http://us.battle.net/d3/en/forum/topic/11040874320#1
    http://us.battle.net/d3/en/forum/topic/11041994180#1
    http://us.battle.net/d3/en/forum/topic/10973337788#1
    http://us.battle.net/d3/en/forum/topic/8198640421?page=1
    http://us.battle.net/d3/en/forum/topic/11041394291#1

    how many?
    so some people have probably wondered at some point "just how many are on this list?"
    well... as fo 3/16/2014 there are at least 233 people on the list above.

    keep in mind that not everyone even posts their problems with this or doesnt post it here. so this number is just a small % of the larger issue. it does show however without doubt that it is a major community issue since it cant be called just a handful of people experiencing the problem.

    edit: update 3/27/2014 281 names on the list above.

    official responses:
    http://us.battle.net/d3/en/forum/topic/8198640421?page=2#30
    03/29/2013 10:07 AMPosted by Liogela
    Just letting you all know that we are actively discussing this issue and what the best steps to proceed with a solution will be. Due to the nature of the issue, I can't promise any specific timetable for when we'll have a solution available, but we do have some ideas, and we will work to have this solved as soon as possible.

    Thank you for the continued reports of the achievements that are broken for you, and please keep them coming. I likely won't be responding to this thread too much more, but rest assured we are still reading it.


    https://us.battle.net/d3/en/forum/topic/12328923227?page=1#11
    04/01/2014 03:31 PMPosted by Tsarnis
    Hi Everyone,

    I want to start by thanking Morogoth for taking the time to create this thread and gather all of this information into one place. We really appreciate it, and the effort you put into this clearly shows the passion you have for our community. I also wanted to take a few moments to provide an update to this issue, and hopefully give you all a bit of insight as to what are doing to address this.

    Currently, we have some work planned to make changes to some of the underlying systems on which the Achievements feature is built and functions. These changes should provide us with the tools to resolve most (if not all) achievement-related issues by allowing achievements to be automatically and retroactively granted when the server detects that your account is missing an achievement that you have completed all of the criteria for. Unfortunately however, the changes needed to make this all work will require a patch to implement. While I cannot provide a specific date for when the necessary work will be completed and our potential solution will be in place, the current goal we have for finishing up this work is around patch 2.1.0. I want to stress that I absolutely cannot make promises about this timeline and that this could happen a bit later based on the progress made on other planned back-end changes between now and then. For now, however, that’s the plan.

    We know this is something that a lot of players have been waiting on for quite some time, and as players ourselves, we sympathize with and share your frustrations. We really appreciate everyone’s patience and hope that this helps you all understand that we aren’t just sitting on our hands over this and that we want this fixed as much as you do. If I have any further information to provide, I will post it here.
  • Hi Everyone,

    I made a post in the last thread, but as that thread had reached its post limit, I'm quoting that reply here for visibility:

    04/01/2014 03:31 PMPosted by Tsarnis
    Hi Everyone,

    I want to start by thanking Morogoth for taking the time to create this thread and gather all of this information into one place. We really appreciate it, and the effort you put into this clearly shows the passion you have for our community. I also wanted to take a few moments to provide an update to this issue, and hopefully give you all a bit of insight as to what are doing to address this.

    Currently, we have some work planned to make changes to some of the underlying systems on which the Achievements feature is built and functions. These changes should provide us with the tools to resolve most (if not all) achievement-related issues by allowing achievements to be automatically and retroactively granted when the server detects that your account is missing an achievement that you have completed all of the criteria for. Unfortunately however, the changes needed to make this all work will require a patch to implement. While I cannot provide a specific date for when the necessary work will be completed and our potential solution will be in place, the current goal we have for finishing up this work is around patch 2.1.0. I want to stress that I absolutely cannot make promises about this timeline and that this could happen a bit later based on the progress made on other planned back-end changes between now and then. For now, however, that’s the plan.

    We know this is something that a lot of players have been waiting on for quite some time, and as players ourselves, we sympathize with and share your frustrations. We really appreciate everyone’s patience and hope that this helps you all understand that we aren’t just sitting on our hands over this and that we want this fixed as much as you do. If I have any further information to provide, I will post it here.
  • 04/01/2014 05:58 PMPosted by Sephiroth
    While today is still April the first.. I'm very greatful to Tsarnis for his reply. ;)


    Good point! I can assure you however, the post was definitely not an April fool's joke!
  • Hi Everyone,

    I just wanted to pop in here and let you all know that we deployed an update to our back end services today that we believe should “heal” a fair amount of the issues that some of you in this thread have been reporting with achievements that have become stuck or “broken” since the game was released.

    Without going too deep into the technical details, basically what we did was implement a system that looks at your account upon login to try and identify any achievements for which you have fulfilled all the criteria, but have not been awarded the actual achievement. If the system identifies a broken achievement, the server will attempt to immediately “heal” your broken achievement and grant it to you. I say “try” because each server will only attempt to run a certain number of instances of this healing operation at one time. What this means is it may take several logins to heal any achievements that are broken on your account in this way. This is expected behavior, and just because you haven’t seen any changes to your achievements just yet, doesn’t mean that the fix did not work for you at all.

    I know that many of you have been waiting for this for a long time, but it is somewhat likely that this fix may not resolve every single achievement issue that every player has. This particular fix is specifically targeted at achievements with tracked criteria (basically this means requirements that were tracked with checkboxes). Also as I said above, this fix may not take effect for everyone immediately. What this means is that we are going to need to let the dust settle over the next few days to see what other types of issues remain.

    So, where do we go from here? At this point, we encourage you to simply play as you normally would for the next several days and see what happens with your achievements. If you are still experiencing erroneous behavior or are missing a particular achievement that you believe is broken, we encourage you to reply to this thread and let us know about it. Include detailed information if you can such as the full achievement name, when you earned it, and what the exact problem with it is with as thorough a description as possible. Steps are good too, if you have them!

    I’ll be watching this thread very closely, and will likely be popping in here again in the days and weeks to come. Thank you all again for your patience and all of your reports about this.
  • 10/24/2014 09:44 AMPosted by Vash
    About the Unique collection achievement, yesterday I killed 3, they got uncheck after I log out. This morning those 3 got cheked again so I went hunting and got another 5 killed. Now these 5 got uncheked like before. Still missing one but what the point in finding it if this crap continues.


    We've heard a few reports about this as well, and while we are still investigating this achievement in particular, one workaround we have found that helps ensure that you retain progress for this is to make sure you stay logged in for 5 to 10 minutes after completing each criteria item. This isn't ideal, but this seems to be a viable workaround.