Both amulets don't have the #1 required stat for an amulet: CHD. I wouldn't use either of them, to be honest. Do you not have another amulet that has at least CHD? You can give up on CHC, int, socket, elemental damage on amulets - but CHD is pretty much a given, in my opinion. Plus, both amulets have a sub-par stat (average damage is quite low on damage and IAS is absolutely useless for jade WD).