I never said that the the enchant he did basically made the weapon into a forogtten sould. What i said is that the weapon would be very beneficial for T5-T6 torments levels with cdr. It still is viable for T5-T6 (as I said i run with no cdr fotf), but it his rerolled crippled it. What I say is that in the long-run he would benefit more in T5-T6 with cdr weapon and what you are saying is "but it is stillgood below T6" (ofc it is, it is a FoTF). That is not an argument. And you are not right that it cannot be tested, It can be, and people have done it. CDR weapon just gives you several viable gearing options, whereas no cdr weapon limits your builds some ways.
No sorry, you said he ruined it, I was exaggerating for effect =)
I guess we just have to agree to disagree about the fact that some people would still consider this a good weapon and that "it's still good below T6" to indeed be an argument.
PS. What I meant could not be proven is if the majority of the player-base would consider the weapon damn good or ruined.
PS2. I believe this discussion has reached its end (at least I've lost interest). I'll retire from this thread; may it live long and prosper and be necro'd in the future.
Ya, he ruined it and that is for a fact, not exageration. You read between the lines, I've explained like 1000 times why he ruined that weapon. Aprat from this, I am not interested in the opinion of below-average T2 crusaders.